The Cynicism Of Biden’s High-Risk, Low-Reward Vaccine Patent Waiver

Must Read


If you are perplexed by the Biden Administration’s announcement about the willingness of Washington to temporarily waive patent protection of vaccines for COVID19 developed and produced by pharmaceutical companies in the name of accelerating the inoculation of mass population segments of poor countries being ravaged by the disease, you are not alone. Even we veteran trade negotiators are scratching our heads. 

The logic behind such a decision is elusive. No matter how quickly the identities of the particular chemical components and the specific steps required to formulate them into vaccines are made public, this will do little, if anything, to move the needle (pardon the pun) one millimeter closer to generating a supply response—that is, getting more COVID19 vaccines into the arms of the people now who otherwise have little chance of doing so for the foreseeable future. 

After all, the recipient countries in question—notably India and South Africa, among the many other emerging markets throughout Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the former Soviet states—lack the modern equipment, the highly trained scientists and the infrastructure in place to actually manufacture and deploy the vaccines.

If Washington was truly interested in getting vaccines in these populations’ arms—and do so before it is too late—there are already viable mechanisms to do so. Think how the U.S.—the federal government, private companies and non-governmental organizations—have responded in the past to help poor countries deal with the aftermath of earthquakes, floods famines, and other natural disasters. 

To be sure, the problem at hand is of a much larger scale and more complex. But if a U.S. President genuinely believes that the degradation of U.S. allies as a result of a pandemic poses significant risks to our own security, there exists the authority for the federal government to procure vaccines from U.S. pharmaceutical companies and deploy them in such countries. 

Indeed, it is even conceivable the U.S. Defense Production Act (DPA) could be invoked by the President to mandate companies to make the needed vaccines under the guise of protecting U.S. national security. Hasn’t it been said enough by Washington that the real goal for dealing effectively with COVID19 is to achieve “herd immunity” not just within the U.S. but also abroad? This is where U.S. health policy, national security policy and economic policy coincide.

Using the DPA in this fashion might strike many as ironic inasmuch as its conventional use has been to prevent exports—recall Trump’s ban on U.S. firms selling PPE abroad—rather than promoting them.

So how did the issue of waiving patent protection for COVID19 vaccines make it to center stage in the White House?

The truth is that for decades many emerging markets have questioned the propriety and logic of advanced countries providing intellectual property protection—of which patents are just one mechanism—to their companies, laboratories, universities, and individuals, among others, for “discoveries” made as a result of engaging in investment in research and development (R&D) and the utilization of other resources, time and effort in analogous creative activities—in areas as diverse as pharmaceuticals, electronics, manufacturing, consumer and retail, and the arts. (For the last, think the age-old problem of China’s piracy of U.S. CDs of music and DVDs of films.)

The logic behind patent protection is straightforward—to ensure, for a well-defined period of time, researchers are able to recoup the commercial rewards for having undertaken high-risk R&D and related activities without such rewards being diluted by the entry of other parties producing the same products but who did not engage in such investments.  The rub in determining how to best structure such incentives, of course, is agreeing not only on what is the “proper” duration for which such protection from competition should last, but also on what is a “fair and reasonable” level of prices that should be charged.

The establishment of the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 1995 brought with it a breakthrough global agreement for the multilateral protection of intellectual property in the guise of the Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) framework. Today, 164 countries are members of the WTO. 

What many non-WTO specialists may not understand is that any changes in the organization’s agreements can only come about by consensus among all 164 of its member states.  It is in this forum that Washington’s proposal for the temporary COVID19 vaccine patent waiver will live or die. 

In this context, the Biden administration’s tactics on this matter are very strange—and that may well be an understatement.

Three points stand out.

First, as the primary advocate for the inclusion of TRIPS into the WTO in the first place, the U.S. has been a steadfast opponent of the long-standing attempts by the emerging market WTO members such as India who have questioned the fundamental fairness of patent protection—except of course when it is their firms who have patents in place. 

Why would Washington now turn around and be seemingly sympathetic to India’s position especially when there would be no response in vaccine supplies?  If Biden thinks the Indians—and the other poor countries in need of COVID19 vaccines now—are not viewing his move as a sham, he is sadly mistaken.

Second, some of the other advanced country members of the WTO—namely Canada, the EU and Switzerland—are extraordinarily lukewarm to such a waiver. They don’t believe for a minute that the “temporary” nature of Washington’s proposal will be sustainable. They are deeply worried it will become an invitation by the poorer country members of the WTO to push for a more fundamental watering down of the integrity of TRIPS.  

Thus the U.S. risks some of its most important allies will oppose its proposal in the WTO. But perhaps that is what Washington is counting on?

Finally, the President chose to have his newly sworn-in U.S. Trade Representative, Katherine Tai, make the announcement about the waiver decision rather than do so himself.  This may be understandable from a mechanical perspective since it is a WTO-specific process that will be the mode for implementing such a policy. 

But it is hard to believe that a seasoned foreign policy practitioner like Biden would not deem it far more appropriate—and impactful—for the President himself to show how caring the U.S. population is towards coming to the aid of important democratic allies under such duress like India. This is all the more striking given how sensitive this White House is toward building a positive narrative of the U.S. role around the globe in contrast to that of the Chinese. Having worked in the White House earlier in my career, you can be sure the decision to have Tai make the announcement instead of the President—or even the Vice President—was not a matter of whimsy.  Whatever it was, it centered on how to best execute a high risk-low reward strategy.           

“Strange” certainly seems to not be the best adjective to describe the new administration’s decision on this matter.  It’s hard not to use the word “cynical.” Let’s hope there is much more to this decision than meets the eye.

- Advertisement -spot_img

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest News

Halle Berry Puts A New Spin On Aging (Part 1 of 3)

You may recognize their names, but what they’re up to may surprise you. Meet three extraordinary superstars who...
- Advertisement -spot_img

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -spot_img
Translate »

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

slot gacor gampang menang

slot gacor hari ini

SBOBET88

Poker

slot gacor hari ini

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Slot Online Bonus New Member

slot resmi

slot gacor hari ini

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Deposit Pulsa

slot resmi

slot resmi

Daftar Poker Online

Situs Slot Online Resmi

slot resmi

Poker

SBOBET88

Daftar Poker Online

Slot Bonus

IDNPLAY

slot resmi

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Situs Slot Online Resmi

Judi Bola

Rtp Slot Gacor

Daftar Poker

slot gacor gampang menang

poker

Slot Gacor Terbaru

Daftar Poker Online

Slot Server Thailand

situs slot gacor

Daftar Poker Online

Daftar Slot Kamboja

Akun Pro Kamboja

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

situs slot gacor

Daftar Poker Online

Situs Slot Online Resmi

Judi Bola

Situs Slot Gacor

IDN Poker

slot resmi

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

IDN Poker

Situs Slot Gacor

Agen SBOBET

slot online resmi

situs slot gacor

Slot Online

Daftar Poker Online

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

slot online resmi

situs slot gacor

Slot Online Via Deposit Dana

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Judi online

Situs Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Daftar Poker Online

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

slot resmi online

slot gacor

Slot gacor Terbaru

slot gacor maxwin

slot resmi online

slot gacor

Situs Slot Resmi

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

IDN Poker

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

slot resmi online

slot gacor

Slot Resmi

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

slot online resmi

slot resmi

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Resmi

Slot Deposit Dana

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

IDN Poker

Slot Resmi

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Situs Slot Resmi

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Akun Pro Myanmar

Slot Resmi

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Online Resmi

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Situs Slot Gacor

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Resmi

Daftar Sbobet

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Gacor Resmi

Slot Gacor Terbaru

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Resmi

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Gacor Resmi

Slot

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Daftar Sbobet

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Deposit Dana

Slot Bonus

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Slot Bonus New Member 100 di Awal

Slot Resmi Online

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Akun Pro Kamboja

Akun Pro Thailand

Slot Gacor Resmi

Situs Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Deposit Dana

Slot Bonus

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Deposit Dana

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Slot Resmi Online

Slot Deposit Pulsa 10 Ribu

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Deposit Via Dana

Slot Resmi Online

Situs Slot Gacor

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

slot gacor gampang menang

slot online resmi

Slot Resmi Online

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Bonus

IDN Poker

Slot Bonus

Slot Pulsa

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Server Kamboja

Slot Garansi Kekalahan 100

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Pulsa

Slot Resmi Online

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

slot online resmi

slot online resmi

Poker

Pragmatic

Pragmatic

Slot Online Resmi

slot online resmi

pragmatic play

Slot Bonus New Member

Pragmatic

Pragmatic

Slot88

Pragmatic

pragmatic play

slot online resmi

Pragmatic Play

Situs Slot88

Pragmatic

Link Slot Gacor

Pragmatic

Slot Pragmatic

slot online resmi

pragmatic play

Situs Slot88

Slot Pragmatic Play

Pragmatic

Situs Slot88

Mahjong Ways 3

Link Slot Gacor

pragmatic play

situs slot88

Slot Bonus New Member

Link Slot Gacor

SBOBET Resmi

SBOBET Resmi

pragmatic play

pragmatic play

pragmatic play

situs slot88

SBOBET88

Slot Online Resmi

RTP Live

RTP Live

link slot demo pragmatic play

Slot Online Resmi

situs slot88

pragmatic play

Slot88 Terpercaya

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Slot Bonus New Member

Situs Pragmatic Play

Slot Demo

pragmatic play

situs slot88

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Slot Online

Slot Gacor

Slot Pragmatic Play

situs slot88

pragmatic play

Slot Bonus New Member

Slot Gacor

Agen Sbobet

Situs Slot88

situs slot88

pragmatic play

RTP Live

Situs SLOT777

Slot Starlight Princess

situs slot88

situs slot88

sbobet88

Slot777 Online

Slot Gacor

situs slot88

SBOBET88

Situs Slot Gacor

Situs SLOT777

sbobet88

situs slot88

Sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Slot Bonus New Member

sbobet88

situs slot88

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Demo Slot Gates of Olympus

Situs Slot88

Slot Pragmatic Play

sbobet88

situs slot88

Mahjong Ways 3

Slot Starlight Princess

Slot 777

sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot Deposit Dana

Situs SLOT777

Slot Pragmatic Play

Slot Mahjong Ways

sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot 777

Slot 777

Daftar Slot88

Slot88 Gacor

Slot Deposit Pulsa

situs slot88

sbobet88

Demo Lucky Neko

SBOBET88

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Situs Slot88

Slot Demo Pragmatic Play

situs slot88

sbobet88

Slot Lucky Neko

Situs Slot88

Slot Lucky Neko

Slot Bonus New Member

Demo Lucky Neko

situs slot88

sbobet88

Mahjong Ways

SBOBET88

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Demo Lucky Neko

situs slot88

sbobet88

Demo Lucky Neko

Demo Slot Gates of Olympus

Slot 777

Joker Gaming

Slot 777

situs slot88

sbobet88

Situs Slot88

Sbobet88

SBOBET88

login joker123

sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot Gacor Maxwin

demo lucky neko

Situs Slot88

SLOT 777

sbobet

slot88

Slot777

Slot Gacor

Slot Deposit

Sbobet

Slot777

situs slot88

sbobet88

Pragmatic

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Situs Slot777

Link Joker123

Slot Bonus New Member

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

sbobet88

Slot 777

RTP Live

SBOBET88

Slot Deposit Pulsa

situs slot88

sbobet88

Slot777 Gacor

RTP Live

Slot88 Gacor

Slot Lucky Neko

Situs Slot777

Slot Bonus New Member

Slot Dana

pragmatic play

Sbobet88

sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Mahjong Ways 2

SBOBET88

Daftar SLot777

Situs Slot88

situs slot88

sbobet88

Joker Gaming

Situs Slot777

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Slot Bonus New Member

situs slot88

sbobet88

Slot Online Resmi

Slot88 Terpercaya

SLOT 777

Slot Bonus New Member

situs slot88

sbobet88

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Resmi

Slot Bonus New Member

RTP Live

situs slot gacor

sbobet88

Slot Resmi Terpercaya

Daftar Sbobet

Pragmatic

SLOT 777

situs slot88

slot gacor

Slot Resmi Terpercaya

Situs Slot77

RTP Live Slot

Slot Bonus New Member

sbobet online

situs slot gacor

Slot Online Resmi

situs slot joker123

SLOT 777

RTP Live

slot gacor hari ini

sbobet88

Daftar Slot777

Slot Resmi Online

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

slot gacor

sbobet88

Situs Slot Resmi

Daftar Slot777

Slot Bonus New Member

SLOT 777

Slot777 Gacor

Pg Soft

slot gacor

sbobet88

Slot Bonus New Member

RTP Live

Slot Resmi Online

situs slot gacor

sbobet online

Link Slot Gacor

SLOT 777

Slot777 Gacor

Mahjong Ways

Slot777 Terpercaya

slot gacor

situs slot88

Mahjong Ways 2

Situs Slot Resmi

Pragmatic

slot gacor

sbobet88

Slot777 Online

Mahjong Ways 2

Slot Mahjong Ways

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Bet 200

Slot Bonus New Member

sbobet88

pragmatic play

Situs Slot777

Slot Mahjong Ways

Slot Server Thailand

RTP Live

sbobet88

pragmatic play

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Gacor777

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Slot Bet Kecil

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Slot Bonus New Member

SBOBET88

Slot Resmi Online

RTP Live

Mahjong Ways 2

Situs Slot777

sbobet88

pragmatic play

Slot Resmi Terpercaya

Slot88 Link Alternatif

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Bet Kecil

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Mahjong Ways

Slot777 Gacor

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Server Thailand

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Mahjong Ways 2

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Demo Lucky Neko

Slot777 Gacor

pragmatic play

sbobet88

RTP Live

Slot Bet Kecil

Slot Thailand

RTP

Slot Mahjong Ways

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

pragmatic play

sbobet88

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Link Alternatif Slot777

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Bet Kecil

Slot Deposit Qris

sbobet88

pragmatic play

RTP Live

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Daftar Slot777

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot777 Gacor

slot88 online

sbobet88

Slot Gacor Terpercaya

Slot88 Terpercaya

Pragmatic

Slot Bonus New Member

slot88 online

sbobet88

Slot Deposit Pulsa

SBOBET88

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Daftar Slot777

slot88 online

sbobet88

Slot Online

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Judi Slot Resmi

Mahjong Ways 2

situs judi Slot88

sbobet88

Slot88 Online

Slot Resmi Online

Pragmatic

Slot Online

sbobet

slot88

Slot88

Slot Resmi

Bonus New Member

Slot Bet 200

pragmatic play

mahjong ways 2

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Mahjong Ways 2

Slot Mahjong

Situs Slot888

Slot88

pragmatic play

akun slot 777

Slot888 Gacor

Slot Online Resmi

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Online

pragmatic play

akun slot 777

Daftar Slot777

Slot88 Online

Slot Online

Slot Bet Kecil

joker123

https://masterclassartacademy.com/wp-includes/poker/

https://headtosole.net/wp-includes/idn-slot/

https://www.iran-pc.com/wp-includes/idn-slot/

https://www.momshousehq.com/wp-includes/idn-poker/

https://petronaji.com/wp-content/idn-poker/

https://saudihome.net/wp-content/togel-online/

https://tikplusuni.com/wp-content/poker-online/

https://azarakhsh.academy/wp-content/ceme-online/

https://discoveryoni.com/wp-includes/sbobet/

https://ezdigitalnews.com/wp-includes/slot-bet-100/

https://parcommstore.com/wp-content/poker-online/

https://haze.io/wp-content/idn-poker/

https://leagueoflearning.co.uk/wp-includes/bonus-new-member/

https://gecmarrakech.com/wp-includes/IDN-SLOT/

https://wtbtool.co.za/wp-content/idn-poker/

https://nbs.edu.mx/wp-content/idn-poker