Parents of dying baby “should have had adjournment” after lawyers withdrew

Must Read


Baker: Strong arguments in favour of granting adjournment

A High Court judge was wrong to refuse an adjournment sought by parents of a brain-damaged baby who lost their legal representation shortly before a hearing on withdrawing treatment, the Court of Appeal has ruled.

Lord Justice Baker said that, although Mr Justice Hayden had been “compassionate and understanding towards the parents” during the hearing, they did not have as central a role in it as they would have done had they been represented.

Baby A was born in April and is being kept alive on a ventilator after sustaining “two devastating injuries to his brain”.

“The medical opinion of the treating clinicians is that there is no hope of any recovery and that he is dying. Although it is impossible to be certain about it, there is no evidence that he is suffering pain,” Baker LJ said. “But his condition is deteriorating rapidly and it is proving very difficult to treat him.”

The parents, despite a good relationship with the clinicians, oppose the trust’s application to permit the withdrawal of treatment due to their Muslim faith, believing “that the decision whether he lives or dies is a matter to be decided by Allah, not by man”, Baker LJ recorded.

At the outset of the hearing late last month, Hayden J refused the application to adjourn to allow the parents to be represented and proceeded to hear evidence. The following day, he ordered that it was lawful and in the baby’s best interests for mechanical ventilation to be withdrawn.

The parents appealed solely on the ground that the refusal to adjourn breached their right to a fair trial.

The court recounted how Irwin Mitchell had been acting for the parents but its application for legal aid was refused on the grounds that the parents’ means exceeded the prescribed limits. Having failed to obtain other funding, Irwin Mitchell withdrew, leaving the parents only three clear days before the hearing to find other representation.

Counsel’s instructions were withdrawn and she was not available to appear pro bono. “Extensive efforts were made by the parents, assisted by the trust’s lawyer, to find alternative [free] representation, to no avail,” Baker LJ said, adding that he was not making any criticism of the lawyers.

The parents told Hayden J that they were working to organise crowdfunding for the legal costs and had identified a lawyer who was able to act for them if they were in funds.

Barrister Bruno Quintavalle – who also acted for the family of Archie Battersbee – and London firm TKD Solicitors, took on the appeal on a pro bono basis.

The Court of Appeal said the judge was wrong to put weight on most of the reasons he gave for refusing the adjournment, such as that the proceedings had already been before the court for over a month and the treating clinicians and court-appointed expert were present to give evidence.

Rather, “there were plainly a number of strong arguments in favour of granting” the adjournment. First was the gravity of the issue and second was the fact that the parents had lost their legal representation only a few days before the hearing through no fault of their own.

“Some parents may choose to represent themselves from the outset and only decide to seek legal representation at the last minute. Others may instruct lawyers and then withdraw those instructions and seek an adjournment. In those circumstances, there is obviously less merit in the adjournment application. In this case, the parents had wanted to be represented at all times.”

He added: “We observe that in future cases it might be advisable to make contingency plans by identifying alternative lawyers who would be available to represent the parents at short notice on a pro bono basis if public funding is refused.”

Third, the task the parents faced in representing themselves in a case of this nature was “daunting”.

Baker LJ said the fact that on paper the medical evidence all seemed to point one way did not mean that the parents should not have an opportunity to challenge it.

“Earlier in this case, the treating clinicians had declared A dead on the basis of several brain stem tests, only to rescind the declaration when he started breathing again,” he observed.

While Hayden J was “typically compassionate and understanding towards the parents” and allowed them to participate in the hearing, “their contributions were limited to the cross-examination of one witness and the giving of unsworn evidence. Their case was not as central to the hearing as it would have been had they been represented”.

The court decided: “In the circumstances, we conclude that the judge’s decision to refuse the adjournment was unfair and must be set aside.”

It did so by applying common law principles of fairness, meaning it was unnecessary to rely separately on article 6. The court said article 6 should not have been the primary argument.

It ordered that the trust’s application be relisted before another judge at the earliest opportunity. “We would hope that legal representation can be obtained, if necessary on a pro bono basis, to enable the substantive hearing to take place in the next two weeks.”

- Advertisement -spot_img

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest News

Halle Berry Puts A New Spin On Aging (Part 1 of 3)

You may recognize their names, but what they’re up to may surprise you. Meet three extraordinary superstars who...
- Advertisement -spot_img

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -spot_img
Translate »

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

slot gacor gampang menang

slot gacor hari ini

SBOBET88

Poker

slot gacor hari ini

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Slot Online Bonus New Member

slot resmi

slot gacor hari ini

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Deposit Pulsa

slot resmi

slot resmi

Daftar Poker Online

Situs Slot Online Resmi

slot resmi

Poker

SBOBET88

Daftar Poker Online

Slot Bonus

IDNPLAY

slot resmi

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Situs Slot Online Resmi

Judi Bola

Rtp Slot Gacor

Daftar Poker

slot gacor gampang menang

poker

Slot Gacor Terbaru

Daftar Poker Online

Slot Server Thailand

situs slot gacor

Daftar Poker Online

Daftar Slot Kamboja

Akun Pro Kamboja

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

situs slot gacor

Daftar Poker Online

Situs Slot Online Resmi

Judi Bola

Situs Slot Gacor

IDN Poker

slot resmi

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

IDN Poker

Situs Slot Gacor

Agen SBOBET

slot online resmi

situs slot gacor

Slot Online

Daftar Poker Online

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

slot online resmi

situs slot gacor

Slot Online Via Deposit Dana

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Judi online

Situs Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Daftar Poker Online

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

slot resmi online

slot gacor

Slot gacor Terbaru

slot gacor maxwin

slot resmi online

slot gacor

Situs Slot Resmi

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

IDN Poker

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

slot resmi online

slot gacor

Slot Resmi

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

slot online resmi

slot resmi

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Resmi

Slot Deposit Dana

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

IDN Poker

Slot Resmi

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Situs Slot Resmi

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Akun Pro Myanmar

Slot Resmi

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Online Resmi

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Situs Slot Gacor

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Resmi

Daftar Sbobet

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Gacor Resmi

Slot Gacor Terbaru

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Resmi

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Gacor Resmi

Slot

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Daftar Sbobet

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Deposit Dana

Slot Bonus

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Slot Bonus New Member 100 di Awal

Slot Resmi Online

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Akun Pro Kamboja

Akun Pro Thailand

Slot Gacor Resmi

Situs Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Deposit Dana

Slot Bonus

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Deposit Dana

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Gacor Maxwin

Slot Resmi Online

Slot Deposit Pulsa 10 Ribu

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Deposit Via Dana

Slot Resmi Online

Situs Slot Gacor

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

slot gacor gampang menang

slot online resmi

Slot Resmi Online

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Bonus

IDN Poker

Slot Bonus

Slot Pulsa

slot online resmi

slot gacor gampang menang

Server Kamboja

Slot Garansi Kekalahan 100

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Pulsa

Slot Resmi Online

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

slot online resmi

slot online resmi

Poker

Pragmatic

Pragmatic

Slot Online Resmi

slot online resmi

pragmatic play

Slot Bonus New Member

Pragmatic

Pragmatic

Slot88

Pragmatic

pragmatic play

slot online resmi

Pragmatic Play

Situs Slot88

Pragmatic

Link Slot Gacor

Pragmatic

Slot Pragmatic

slot online resmi

pragmatic play

Situs Slot88

Slot Pragmatic Play

Pragmatic

Situs Slot88

Mahjong Ways 3

Link Slot Gacor

pragmatic play

situs slot88

Slot Bonus New Member

Link Slot Gacor

SBOBET Resmi

SBOBET Resmi

pragmatic play

pragmatic play

pragmatic play

situs slot88

SBOBET88

Slot Online Resmi

RTP Live

RTP Live

link slot demo pragmatic play

Slot Online Resmi

situs slot88

pragmatic play

Slot88 Terpercaya

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Slot Bonus New Member

Situs Pragmatic Play

Slot Demo

pragmatic play

situs slot88

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Slot Online

Slot Gacor

Slot Pragmatic Play

situs slot88

pragmatic play

Slot Bonus New Member

Slot Gacor

Agen Sbobet

Situs Slot88

situs slot88

pragmatic play

RTP Live

Situs SLOT777

Slot Starlight Princess

situs slot88

situs slot88

sbobet88

Slot777 Online

Slot Gacor

situs slot88

SBOBET88

Situs Slot Gacor

Situs SLOT777

sbobet88

situs slot88

Sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Slot Bonus New Member

sbobet88

situs slot88

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Demo Slot Gates of Olympus

Situs Slot88

Slot Pragmatic Play

sbobet88

situs slot88

Mahjong Ways 3

Slot Starlight Princess

Slot 777

sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot Deposit Dana

Situs SLOT777

Slot Pragmatic Play

Slot Mahjong Ways

sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot 777

Slot 777

Daftar Slot88

Slot88 Gacor

Slot Deposit Pulsa

situs slot88

sbobet88

Demo Lucky Neko

SBOBET88

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Situs Slot88

Slot Demo Pragmatic Play

situs slot88

sbobet88

Slot Lucky Neko

Situs Slot88

Slot Lucky Neko

Slot Bonus New Member

Demo Lucky Neko

situs slot88

sbobet88

Mahjong Ways

SBOBET88

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Demo Lucky Neko

situs slot88

sbobet88

Demo Lucky Neko

Demo Slot Gates of Olympus

Slot 777

Joker Gaming

Slot 777

situs slot88

sbobet88

Situs Slot88

Sbobet88

SBOBET88

login joker123

sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot Gacor Maxwin

demo lucky neko

Situs Slot88

SLOT 777

sbobet

slot88

Slot777

Slot Gacor

Slot Deposit

Sbobet

Slot777

situs slot88

sbobet88

Pragmatic

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Situs Slot777

Link Joker123

Slot Bonus New Member

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

sbobet88

Slot 777

RTP Live

SBOBET88

Slot Deposit Pulsa

situs slot88

sbobet88

Slot777 Gacor

RTP Live

Slot88 Gacor

Slot Lucky Neko

Situs Slot777

Slot Bonus New Member

Slot Dana

pragmatic play

Sbobet88

sbobet88

situs slot88

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Mahjong Ways 2

SBOBET88

Daftar SLot777

Situs Slot88

situs slot88

sbobet88

Joker Gaming

Situs Slot777

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Slot Bonus New Member

situs slot88

sbobet88

Slot Online Resmi

Slot88 Terpercaya

SLOT 777

Slot Bonus New Member

situs slot88

sbobet88

Daftar Sbobet

Slot Resmi

Slot Bonus New Member

RTP Live

situs slot gacor

sbobet88

Slot Resmi Terpercaya

Daftar Sbobet

Pragmatic

SLOT 777

situs slot88

slot gacor

Slot Resmi Terpercaya

Situs Slot77

RTP Live Slot

Slot Bonus New Member

sbobet online

situs slot gacor

Slot Online Resmi

situs slot joker123

SLOT 777

RTP Live

slot gacor hari ini

sbobet88

Daftar Slot777

Slot Resmi Online

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

slot gacor

sbobet88

Situs Slot Resmi

Daftar Slot777

Slot Bonus New Member

SLOT 777

Slot777 Gacor

Pg Soft

slot gacor

sbobet88

Slot Bonus New Member

RTP Live

Slot Resmi Online

situs slot gacor

sbobet online

Link Slot Gacor

SLOT 777

Slot777 Gacor

Mahjong Ways

Slot777 Terpercaya

slot gacor

situs slot88

Mahjong Ways 2

Situs Slot Resmi

Pragmatic

slot gacor

sbobet88

Slot777 Online

Mahjong Ways 2

Slot Mahjong Ways

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Bet 200

Slot Bonus New Member

sbobet88

pragmatic play

Situs Slot777

Slot Mahjong Ways

Slot Server Thailand

RTP Live

sbobet88

pragmatic play

Slot Online Resmi

Slot Gacor777

Slot Deposit Pulsa

Slot Bet Kecil

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Slot Bonus New Member

SBOBET88

Slot Resmi Online

RTP Live

Mahjong Ways 2

Situs Slot777

sbobet88

pragmatic play

Slot Resmi Terpercaya

Slot88 Link Alternatif

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Bet Kecil

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Mahjong Ways

Slot777 Gacor

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Server Thailand

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Mahjong Ways 2

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Demo Lucky Neko

Slot777 Gacor

pragmatic play

sbobet88

RTP Live

Slot Bet Kecil

Slot Thailand

RTP

Slot Mahjong Ways

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

pragmatic play

sbobet88

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Link Alternatif Slot777

Slot Gacor Hari Ini

Slot Bet Kecil

Slot Deposit Qris

sbobet88

pragmatic play

RTP Live

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

pragmatic play

sbobet88

Daftar Slot777

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot777 Gacor

slot88 online

sbobet88

Slot Gacor Terpercaya

Slot88 Terpercaya

Pragmatic

Slot Bonus New Member

slot88 online

sbobet88

Slot Deposit Pulsa

SBOBET88

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Daftar Slot777

slot88 online

sbobet88

Slot Online

Slot Garansi Kekalahan

Judi Slot Resmi

Mahjong Ways 2

situs judi Slot88

sbobet88

Slot88 Online

Slot Resmi Online

Pragmatic

Slot Online

sbobet

slot88

Slot88

Slot Resmi

Bonus New Member

Slot Bet 200

pragmatic play

mahjong ways 2

Slot Gacor Gampang Menang

Slot Mahjong Ways 2

Slot Mahjong

Situs Slot888

Slot88

pragmatic play

akun slot 777

Slot888 Gacor

Slot Online Resmi

Slot777 Gacor

Slot Online

pragmatic play

akun slot 777

Daftar Slot777

Slot88 Online

Slot Online

Slot Bet Kecil

joker123

https://masterclassartacademy.com/wp-includes/poker/

https://headtosole.net/wp-includes/idn-slot/

https://www.iran-pc.com/wp-includes/idn-slot/

https://www.momshousehq.com/wp-includes/idn-poker/

https://petronaji.com/wp-content/idn-poker/

https://saudihome.net/wp-content/togel-online/

https://tikplusuni.com/wp-content/poker-online/

https://azarakhsh.academy/wp-content/ceme-online/

https://discoveryoni.com/wp-includes/sbobet/

https://ezdigitalnews.com/wp-includes/slot-bet-100/

https://parcommstore.com/wp-content/poker-online/

https://haze.io/wp-content/idn-poker/

https://leagueoflearning.co.uk/wp-includes/bonus-new-member/

https://gecmarrakech.com/wp-includes/IDN-SLOT/

https://wtbtool.co.za/wp-content/idn-poker/

https://nbs.edu.mx/wp-content/idn-poker